Browse by musical

Jesus Christ Superstar: Musical cast


Jesus Christ Superstar cast


Original Broadway Cast: Jesus Christ Superstar (1971).

Principal Cast Members.

  • Jesus of Nazareth – Jeff Fenholt
  • Judas Iscariot – Ben Vereen
  • Mary Magdalene – Yvonne Elliman
  • Pontius Pilate – Barry Dennen
  • King Herod – Paul Ainsley
  • Caiaphas – Bob Bingham
  • Annas – Phil Jethro
  • Simon Zealotes – Dennis Buckley
  • Peter – Michael Jason

Ensemble and Supporting Roles.

  • Priests – Steven Bell, Alan Braunstein, Michael Meadows
  • Reporters – Robalee Barnes, Ferne Bork, Kay Cole, Pi Douglass, Doug Lucas, Anita Morris, Ted Neeley, Bonnie Schon, Margaret Warncke, Willie Windsor, Samuel E. Wright, Kurt Yaghjian
  • Soldiers – Tony Gardner, Tom Stovall, Paul Sylvan, Eddie Barton
  • Judas' Tormentors – Eddie Barton, Tony Gardner
  • Temple Ladies – Robin Grean, Martha Deering
  • Chorus Members – Robert Barnes, Edward Barton, Celia Brin, Dennis Buckley, Charlotte Crossley, Denise Delapenha, Michael Jason, Melvin Laszczynski, Clifford Lipson, Laura Michaels, Nathanial Morris, Janet Powell, Linda Rios, James Sbano, Peter Schlosser, Tom Stovall, Paul Sylvan, Margaret Warncke, Willie Windsor, Samuel Wright, Kurt Yaghjian

Notable Understudies and Replacements.

  • Jesus of Nazareth – Dennis Cooley (replacement)
  • Mary Magdalene – Kate Dezina, Marta Heflin (replacements)
  • Caiaphas – Stephen Klein (replacement)
  • Soul Girls – Realinda Farrell, Gail Boggs (replacements)
  • Third Priest – William Parry (replacement)
  • Apostle Woman / Cured Leper / Reporter / Temple Lady – Martha Deering (replacement)

Production Details.

  • Opening Date: October 12, 1971
  • Theatre: Mark Hellinger Theatre, New York City
  • Director: Tom O’Horgan
  • Music: Andrew Lloyd Webber
  • Lyrics: Tim Rice
  • Set Design: Robin Wagner
  • Costume Design: Randy Barcelo
  • Lighting Design: Jules Fisher
  • Musical Direction: Marc Pressel

Legacy and Impact.

  • Performance Run: 711 performances, closing on June 30, 1973
  • Awards: Nominated for five Tony Awards; Ben Vereen won a Theatre World Award; Andrew Lloyd Webber received a Drama Desk Award for Most Promising Composer
  • Controversy: The production faced criticism from religious groups for its portrayal of biblical figures and themes
  • Innovations: One of the first rock operas to be performed on Broadway, noted for its sung-through format and contemporary musical style

Last Update:June, 02nd 2025

Jesus Christ Superstar Lyrics: Song List

  1. Act 1
  2. Overture
  3. Heaven On Their Minds
  4. What's The Buzz
  5. Then We Are Decided
  6. Strange Thing Mystifying
  7. Everything's Alright
  8. This Jesus Must Die
  9. Hosanna
  10. Simon Zealotes
  11. Poor Jerusalem
  12. Pilate's Dream
  13. The Temple
  14. I Don't Know How To Love Him
  15. Damned For All Time / Blood Money
  16. Act 2
  17. The Last Supper
  18. Gethsemane (I Only Want To Say)
  19. The Arrest
  20. Peter's Denial
  21. Pilate And Christ
  22. King Herod's Song (Try It And See)
  23. Could We Start Again Please?
  24. Judas' Death
  25. Trial Before Pilate
  26. Superstar
  27. The Crucifixion
  28. John Nineteen: Forty-One

Popular musicals