Exploring the Iconic 'What Is This Feeling?' from Wicked
Song Credits
- Artist: Kristin Chenoweth & Idina Menzel
- Song Writer: Stephen Schwartz
- Producer: Stephen Schwartz
- Label: Decca Broadway
- Release Date: December 16, 2003
- Album: Wicked (15th Anniversary Special Edition)
- Musical Genre: Pop, Broadway
- Language: English
Song Meaning
Loathing as a Subtle Reflection of Attraction
The irony of the song is that the language used is similar to that of a love song. Phrases like “What is this feeling, so sudden and new?” and “My pulse is rushing, my head is reeling” are typically found in romantic songs, but here they are used to describe the mutual loathing Elphaba and Galinda feel for each other. The comedic twist is that these feelings are not of love but of repulsion, which adds both humor and depth to the character dynamics. The juxtaposition of superficial judgments made by both characters (Elphaba criticizes Galinda’s voice, and Galinda criticizes Elphaba’s looks) illustrates their initial inability to look beyond external features. This sets up a poignant commentary on how society often judges individuals based on surface traits rather than their true character.Symbolism and Foreshadowing
There is also foreshadowing in the song. As Galinda sings, “rise above it,” she hits a higher note than Elphaba, symbolizing her eventual rise in social status, while Elphaba remains in the shadows for much of the story. This line not only reflects Galinda's future role as an aide to the Wizard but also hints at the literal rise that both characters will experience — with Elphaba soaring on her broomstick and Galinda floating in her bubble. It is a clever use of word painting, with musical notes mirroring the characters' emotional trajectories.The Subtext of Attraction
The song’s lighthearted portrayal of intense dislike is also filled with subtext. The strong emotions they express in their loathing may hint at deeper, more complex feelings, including a possible sexual attraction. This is a theme that *Wicked* subtly plays with throughout, as evidenced by the dynamic between the two women. In Gregory Maguire’s novel, which inspired *Wicked*, there is a suggestion of romantic tension between the two characters, and this tension continues to be explored in the musical.Songs Sharing Similar Themes
- 'Defying Gravity' from Wicked (Idina Menzel): This song marks Elphaba’s declaration of independence as she chooses to embrace her true self, despite society’s rejection. It contrasts with 'What Is This Feeling?' as it marks a shift from the antagonism between Galinda and Elphaba to a moment of self-empowerment and freedom.
- 'You Can't Stop the Beat' from Hairspray (Multiple Artists): Like 'What Is This Feeling?', this song celebrates freedom and individuality but through the lens of an energetic group number. Both songs emphasize defiance against societal norms, but 'You Can't Stop the Beat' is more exuberant in its energy.
- 'Take Me or Leave Me' from Rent (Idina Menzel & Tracie Thoms): This song explores the complex dynamic between two characters who are deeply intertwined but struggling with their differences. It shares the combative and emotional energy of 'What Is This Feeling?' while touching on themes of love, hate, and everything in between.
Questions and Answers
- What does the phrase "unadulterated loathing" mean in 'What Is This Feeling?'
- The phrase refers to pure, unfiltered hatred. Both Elphaba and Galinda use it to describe their intense dislike for each other, which is the central theme of the song.
- How does the song foreshadow the future relationship between Elphaba and Galinda?
- While initially filled with hatred, the song’s dynamic hints at the underlying connection between the two characters. Their futures are deeply intertwined, as they eventually form a bond of friendship despite their rocky start.
- What is the significance of the word "loathing" in the song?
- The use of "loathing" instead of "love" in a song that mimics a traditional love song creates irony and humor. It reflects the antagonism between the characters and also serves as a playful subversion of the romantic trope often seen in musicals.
Awards and Chart Positions
- 'What Is This Feeling?' has become one of the most recognized numbers from *Wicked*, gaining significant attention in the musical theater community and being frequently performed in Broadway concerts and special editions.
- The 15th Anniversary Special Edition of *Wicked* was met with critical acclaim and strong chart performances, solidifying its place as one of the most beloved musicals of all time.
Fan and Media Reactions
"The chemistry between Kristin and Idina in this song is perfect. They play off each other’s energy so well, and it’s so fun to watch!" — Broadway fan.
"I love how 'What Is This Feeling?' captures the essence of their rivalry. It’s hilarious but also so telling of their personalities." — Theatergoer on YouTube.
"This song perfectly encapsulates the humor and depth of the characters. Their animosity is both comedic and relatable, and the song's structure makes it memorable." — Musical theater critic.