Schmigadoon!: Musical cast

Schmigadoon! Cast - Broadway musical

“Schmigadoon!” — Cast (TV Series & Stage)

TV Series — Main Cast (Seasons 1–2)

• Keegan-Michael Key — Josh Skinner (S1–S2)
• Cecily Strong — Melissa Gimble (S1–S2)
• Fred Armisen — Rev. Howard Layton (S1)
• Dove Cameron — Betsy McDonough (S1); Jenny Banks (S2)
• Jaime Camil — Doc Jorge Lopez (S1); Sgt. Rivera (S2)
• Kristin Chenoweth — Mildred Layton (S1); Miss Codwell (S2)
• Alan Cumming — Mayor Aloysius Menlove (S1); Dooley Blight (S2)
• Ariana DeBose — Emma Tate (S1); Emcee (S2)
• Ann Harada — Florence Menlove (S1); Madam Frau (S2)
• Jane Krakowski — Countess Gabriele von Blerkom (S1); Bobbie Flanagan (S2)
• Martin Short — Leprechaun (S1)
• Aaron Tveit — Danny Bailey (S1); Topher (S2)

Season 2 (“Schmicago”) Additions

• Tituss Burgess — Narrator (S2)
• Patrick Page — Octavius Kratt (S2)

Stage Musical — Kennedy Center World Premiere (Jan–Feb 2025)

• Alex Brightman — Josh Skinner
• Sara Chase — Melissa Gimble
• Isabelle McCalla — Emma Tate
• Kevin Del Aguila — Reverend Layton / Leprechaun
• Ryan Vasquez — Danny Bailey
• Emily Skinner — Mildred Layton
• Javier Muñoz — Doc Lopez
• Ann Harada — Florence Menlove
• Angel Reda — Countess von Blerkom
• Brad Oscar — Mayor Menlove
• McKenzie Kurtz — Betsy McDonough

Direction & choreography: Christopher Gattelli.

Broadway Transfer — Nederlander Theatre (Previews from Apr 4, 2026)

• Alex Brightman — Josh Skinner (announced)
• Sara Chase — Melissa Gimble (announced)

Additional Broadway casting to be announced by The Telsey Office.